Alright, let’s talk about André Schürrle and his time at Dortmund. I remember when the news broke, you know? It was a big deal, or at least it felt like it at the time.

My Initial Thoughts and What I Did
So, the first thing I did, like probably many fans, was get a bit excited. We’re talking about a World Cup winner here! I immediately started thinking about how he’d fit into the team. Big expectations, definitely. I went online, read a few articles, talked with mates down at the pub. We all sort of agreed, this could be good.
I made sure to watch his first few games, really paid attention. You’re looking for those sparks, those moments that make you go “yep, good signing.”
The Experience Unfolding
And well, the actual experience of watching him over his stint there… it was a bit of a rollercoaster, but mostly the kind that doesn’t have many thrilling ups.
There were flashes, don’t get me wrong. A decent goal here, a good run there. But consistency? That was the tough part.
And then the injuries started piling up. It felt like every other week, you’d hear Schürrle was out again. Super frustrating, that was.

I kept tabs, you know? Followed the injury reports, hoped for a strong comeback each time. You want players to succeed, especially when they come with that kind of price tag and reputation. But it just seemed like one thing after another.
- We hoped for goals, lots of them.
- We hoped for that cutting edge he showed for Germany.
- We hoped he’d link up well with the other attackers.
But it often felt like he was playing with the handbrake on, or just unlucky. Maybe the pressure was too much, or the fit wasn’t quite right. Hard to say from the outside, innit?
Looking Back at It
When I think back on the whole Schürrle-Dortmund saga, it’s mostly a feeling of “what if?”. What if he’d stayed fit? What if things had just clicked a bit better?
I spent a good amount of time watching those matches, discussing his performances. It wasn’t for lack of trying to see the best, believe me. But the end result, well, it wasn’t what anyone hoped for, I reckon. Not him, not the club, not the fans like me who were initially buzzing.

It’s one of those transfers that just didn’t pan out as planned. A real shame, to be honest. He had the talent, no doubt about that. But for Dortmund, it just felt like a story of unfulfilled promise. That’s my take on it, from what I saw and followed during his time there. Just one of those things in football, I suppose.