Man, this whole thing started because I was watching last night’s Premier League match – total snoozefest honestly. Teams barely moving, zero passion. Got me thinking: what’s the absolute craziest, angriest game ever? Like when players just lost their damn minds. Obviously meant red cards. So I sat my butt down this morning determined to dig up the record.

The Frustrating Search
Opened my laptop ready to find this answer fast. Searched “most red cards in one football match.” Easy, right? WRONG. Got flooded with clickbait articles listing dumb stuff like “Top 10 Angry Players!” or “Famous Red Card Moments.” Useless. Couldn’t find an actual number anywhere. Felt like every website just copied each other without any real facts. Even tried different wordings like “highest red cards single game.” Nada. Zip. Almost gave up.
Then I remembered this super niche football database forum mentioned ages ago. Took me twenty minutes just to find the dang login details scribbled on a sticky note. Of course, my password was expired. Had to reset it, waiting for that email… annoying. Finally got in.
The Holy Grail Moment
Started digging through old forum threads about disciplinary records. Man, people argue hardcore over referee decisions from like 1985! Scrolled forever. Found a thread titled “Ref lost the plot??” Bingo. Old-timers were arguing about some Argentina game. Got a name: Claypole vs. Victoriano Arenas. Huh? Never heard of ’em. Kept reading.
Found the mind-blowing facts:
- 36 red cards in a single match. Yep, THIRTY-SIX.
- Happened in 2011 down in Argentina. Low tier regional league madness.
- Ref sent off every single player on both teams. Plus subs. Plus the coaches. And a random guy on the bench!
- Started with a goal fight. Then a mass brawl. Then subs joined. Then coaches punched each other.
- Ref just whipped out red after red after red like confetti.
Couldn’t believe it. That’s like WWE with football shirts! Found some blurry YouTube clips too. Absolute chaos. Looked like a riot.

Compared it to famous games everyone talks about, like Holland vs. Portugal (“Battle of Nuremberg” – 16 yellows, 4 reds). Total amateurs compared to this Argentina madness!
Why This is Just Bonkers
Think about it. A team has what? 11 players. Some subs. Maybe 14 people per side. This ref sent off MORE THAN THE TOTAL PLAYERS PRESENT. Means he sent off players who were already sent off! Like handing red cards to ghosts! Makes zero sense. Officially ended 0-0 because… well, no players left to play! Just insanity. Stuff like this makes you wonder if football ever needs rules anymore.
Made my notes, wrote down the key details. Definitely beats my boring Thursday. Honestly, after finding this, yesterday’s Premier League snorefest almost looks professional. Almost.
Just shows you – you dig deep enough into any “craziest record” story, and you’ll find some truly wild stuff happening where you least expect it. Usually involves people losing their minds somewhere in South America. Lesson learned? Don’t mess with passionate guys in low-tier leagues. And maybe bring popcorn to those games instead. Man, what a bad day for anyone selling red cards – probably ran out!